Illinois Food

Community rallies around one of Nashville’s oldest Chicago-style pizza joints as it faces closure: ‘Our last Hail Mary’

Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr

What This Story Is About

312 Pizza, a family-owned Chicago-style pizzeria in Nashville’s Germantown neighborhood, nearly closed this week before a surge of community support gave it a temporary reprieve.

Why It Matters

Owner Kimberly Wolff said revenue is down roughly 25% this year, reflecting broader financial pressure on small, local businesses in Nashville.

What Happens Next

Wolff said the weekend surge in orders bought the business a couple of weeks, but survival depends on customers returning consistently rather than only during a crisis.

For Context

Wolff’s parents put their retirement savings into opening the restaurant 12 years ago after she found no Chicago-style pizza available in Nashville.

Catch Up

312 Pizza posted a message asking for help before it was set to close Monday, and hundreds of orders came in from the community over Labor Day weekend.

NASHVILLE, Tenn. (WSMV) – 312 Pizza posted a final call for help as the business was set to close its doors this past Monday. The community responded this past weekend, giving the shop hope of staying open.

Chicago roots in Nashville

312 Pizza starts each day by sectioning off pieces of dough and turning them into family-owned pies with Chicago roots. The restaurant opened 12 years ago in Germantown.

“When I moved to Nashville in 2011, there was no Chicago pizza here. It just did not exist,” owner Kimberly Wolff said. “That’s the first thing we looked for when we were unpacking is, where can we get a pizza? And our realtor was like, there’s a chain pizza down the road. And we were like, that’s not quite what we were hoping for.”

When Wolff saw that gap, her parents saw a risk worth taking.

“We’ve had these recipes in our family for several generations. My mom and dad were like, ‘Well, why don’t we bring it to Nashville?’ So they put up their retirement,” Wolff said.

Wolff said her father did the restaurant’s entire build-out from start to finish, and the space was a gravel floor before construction.

Wolff said the restaurant had a line of people down the block waiting to get in from the day it opened.

“We just realized there is a need for Chicago pizza in Nashville. And now there’s so many Chicagoans that move here that are, they’re all looking for a taste of home,” Wolff said. “And even if you’re not from Chicago, we get so many people that are like, oh, we’ve had Chicago pizza and we want to come eat it again.”

For 12 years, they have anchored the corner of Fourth and Monroe with Chicago deep dish.

Wolff said the restaurant was busy from the moment it opened, including drawing customers for hot dogs and pizza before Nashville Sounds games — at least until the stadium’s ballpark existed at its current site.

“As Nashville has changed and this neighborhood has changed, I mean, the neighborhood looks nothing like it did 12 years ago,” Wolff said. “There’s a lot more restaurants and other businesses and, of course, a lot more residential that has moved in.”

Wolff said foot traffic has slowed as more dining and entertainment options have opened nearby, including additional activity across from the Sounds stadium.

“So we did notice a little downtick as the neighborhood has grown. And, of course, we went through COVID and we survived the chaos of that,” Wolff said.

312 Pizza owner Kimberly Wolff posted what was supposed to be a goodbye video to Instagram. It...312 Pizza owner Kimberly Wolff posted what was supposed to be a goodbye video to Instagram. It turned into a rallying cry for the community who supports them.(Steve Mehling)Revenue down 25%

In the last year, Wolff said the numbers stopped working. Revenue is down roughly 25% compared to last year, and Wolff said this year has been difficult.

“This year in particular, 2026 is, I would say, one of the hardest financially that we have ever experienced,” Wolff said. “It’s one of our slowest years that we’ve ever had so far. I mean, we’re only in September.”

Wolff attributed the decline to slower customer flow.

“I think that just the way the economy is and maybe people are pulling back their spending,” Wolff said. “A lot of things have just gone up in price across the board for small businesses; those two things combined is just crushing local businesses.”

Wolff said other restaurant and small business owners have told her they are experiencing the same struggles.

Wolff said the last couple of months were spent trying to strategize solutions. She said last Thursday, “things came to an abrupt halt, and we were out of solutions.”

“My mom and dad put their retirement into it. I mean, the last thing I want is for, you know, my mom especially, to just be left with nothing,” Wolff said.

Wolff said she called Brandon from the Nashville Area Restaurant Alliance to tell him the restaurant was closing on Monday. She said he asked her to do an interview before making the closure final.

“I mean, our last Hail Mary, either we go out and we say that we tried everything we possibly could, or we just go out,” Wolff said.

Community response

A final social media post was intended as a goodbye. Wolff said the response from the community was overwhelming, and staff worked from open to close Saturday through Monday without stopping.

“Our bodies are aching. But I’m also very grateful that they are because that means that people do love and support us and care about us and they want us here,” Wolff said.

Wolff said the restaurant started Monday three staff members short, with no cheese or dough on hand, and a supply truck that arrived 10 minutes before opening.

“I was so overwhelmed by the support from our community. I mean, I was overwhelmed to the point where tears were just flowing down my face,” Wolff said. She said three customers offered to help bus tables during the rush.

Wolff said a packed house watching a Cubs game on Monday reflected what the restaurant has always aimed to be.

“This is what 312 has always been. And we just want that community back in here where we’re watching a game and eating pizza and drinking a beer together,” Wolff said.

Looking for consistent support

The surge bought the business a couple of weeks, not a guarantee. Wolff said the restaurant does not need another weekend like the one it just had, but instead needs steady customer flow like it had a few years ago.

She said the business is also working internally on ways to improve the customer experience to help ensure people keep coming back.

Wolff said she would like to see more state-level support for small, local businesses, saying that money spent locally stays in the community.

“I would love to see more support from a state level to support the small local businesses because we’re dying here,” Wolff said.

Wolff said she hopes people will support their favorite local businesses regularly, not just during a crisis.

“Whatever neighborhood you’re in, hit them up at least once a week if you can. If you have the means to do that, like, don’t forget about those places that you love because they might not be there much longer,” Wolff said.

Copyright 2026 WSMV. All rights reserved.

Write A Comment