Steakhouse

Clementine’s prepares to serve its final slice | Business

Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr

Ror more than 50 years, walking into Clementine’s Steak House meant knowing a few things before you ever sat down.

You probably weren’t going home hungry. There was a good chance a takeout container would accompany you out the door. And somewhere between the homemade soup and salad and the arrival of an enormous plate of fried chicken, prime rib or steak, someone at the table was already contemplating the most important decision of the evening: Which slice of homemade pie?

Soon, Carpinterians will have to make that choice one last time.

Clementine’s, the longtime steakhouse at 4631 Carpinteria Ave., will close its doors for good Sunday, Oct. 4, bringing to an end more than half a century of home cooking and a family restaurant tradition that has become woven into Carpinteria life.

The restaurant announced the news last week on social media, thanking the generations of customers and employees who have passed through its doors.

“To our friends, neighbors, guests and staff: Your friendship, loyalty and support made Clementine’s the beloved landmark it has become,” the announcement read.

Owner and chef Lloyd McLenithan told CVN that the building and property sold, bringing an end to a chapter he and his family always knew would eventually close because they did not own the property.

What he didn’t anticipate was the community’s reaction when that day finally arrived.

“The response to Clementine’s closing has been overwhelming,” McLenithan told CVN.

In the days following the announcement, he said he was averaging about four hours of sleep while working 16-hour days trying to keep the kitchen going. Reservations quickly filled through the restaurant’s final weekend, to the point, he said, of being “almost overbooked.”

And when Clementine’s says the kitchen has been busy, there’s a reason.

“When we always said we did things from scratch, that means I do that,” McLenithan said.

 

A family tradition

Clementine’s opened in 1976, but the McLenithan family’s chapter began in 1982 when Lloyd’s mother, Irene McLenithan, took over the restaurant on April 30 — her 52nd birthday.

A 2007 Coastal View News business profile described Irene as the mother of seven who had experience in food service and a love of large family gatherings. When she took over Clementine’s, Lloyd and his sister Esther joined her.

“Clementine’s had a good name,” Irene told CVN at the time. “It was home cooking and that’s what we were about.”

That philosophy never changed much.

Lloyd became Clementine’s head chef, and the restaurant resisted the temptation to chase culinary trends. Fish and vegetables were brought in fresh, meats were cut in-house and soups and salad dressings were made in the kitchen.

“We’re completely hands on,” Lloyd told CVN in 2007. “Nobody else does our job.”

Consistency became part of the Clementine’s identity. Irene recalled customers returning to Carpinteria after years away and asking whether an old favorite was still on the menu.

“They do appreciate the consistency,” she said.

Irene died in August 2016, and Lloyd carried on the family tradition. A message on the restaurant’s current menu describes Clementine’s as his mother’s “home away from home” and says Lloyd continued her legacy by “pouring his heart and soul into every dish.”

 

Dinner — and don’t forget the pie

Clementine’s was never really about grabbing a quick bite.

Dinner was dinner.

The traditional full-course meal became one of the restaurant’s signatures, with soup, salad, vegetables, potatoes or rice, bread and dessert accompanying the entree. Favorites through the years included fried chicken, prime rib, New York steak and filet mignon.

And then there were the pies.

In 2007, Clementine’s offered no fewer than 15 varieties. Lloyd explained at the time that including dessert was part of giving customers a complete meal.

“You’d be hard pressed to find a restaurant that serves dessert with a meal,” he said. “We consider it a better value.”

It was an old-fashioned approach that fit an old-fashioned restaurant — right down to the fresh flowers on the tables and the feeling that dinner should be an occasion rather than a transaction.

That philosophy is still spelled out on Clementine’s menu today: “At Clementine’s, we welcome our guests as family and old friends.”

Judging by the response to the closing announcement, plenty of customers took them at their word.

McLenithan said it had long been common knowledge among regulars that his family did not own the property and “the clock was ticking.” Still, he said, “I completely underestimated the response.”

There will be more to tell about Clementine’s after the ovens cool, the last plates are cleared and McLenithan finally gets some sleep. CVN plans to sit down with him in the coming weeks to look back at the restaurant’s history, its challenges, its blessings and the family behind a Carpinteria institution.

For now, there are meals to cook.

And, for a few more days, pie to choose.

Write A Comment