An Ogle County judge on Tuesday denied a defense request to end the reckless homicide trial of a former Carroll County sheriff’s deputy after prosecutors rested their case.
Matthew Herpstreith, 46, of Savanna, is charged with reckless homicide, a Class 3 felony; reckless conduct and obstructing justice, both Class 4 felonies; attempting to obstruct justice by destroying evidence, a Class A misdemeanor; and failure to reduce speed to avoid an accident, a petty offense, in the death of 18-year-old Jackson Kradle of Mount Carroll. Herpstreith pleaded not guilty to all charges at his arraignment in April 2025.
Kradle’s body was found at 3:30 a.m. July 28, 2024, on Route 78, less than a mile north of Mount Carroll’s city limits. Kradle was the victim of blunt force trauma, which a forensic pathologist ruled was the result of a vehicle/pedestrian crash.
Herpstreith and former Carroll County dispatcher Amy Hubble, who were off duty at the time, called the Carroll County dispatch center via its nonemergency line and told officers that they had found the body on the highway. The charges against Herpstreith were filed about eight months later. No charges have been filed against Hubble, and she was granted immunity to testify at trial.
A Carroll County jury was seated Nov. 9 after one day of jury selection. Ogle County Associate Judge Anthony Peska is presiding over the trial that began Monday with testimony from Kradle’s girlfriend Maddie Stephens and eight law enforcement members.
On Tuesday, eight people took the stand, including Hubble, a Carroll County dispatcher, two of Kradle’s family members, two Illinois State Police investigators and two experts.
Special prosecutors Charles Colburn and Derek Dion of the Illinois Appellate Prosecutor’s Office rested the state’s case in the late afternoon. Outside the presence of jurors, Herpstreith’s attorney Joseph E. Nack asked Peska for a directed verdict.
“It doesn’t matter if my client drove over Jackson Kradle. They have to prove he acted recklessly,” Nack said.
Nack argued that the evidence and testimony presented by prosecutors were insufficient to prove their allegations specifically for the charges of reckless homicide and conduct.
Hubble testified that she was in the front passenger seat as Herpstreith drove northbound on Route 78 sometime between 2 a.m. and 3:30 a.m. the day Kradle’s body was found.
“I heard Matt [Herpstreith] say there’s a deer,” Hubble said. “All I saw was a flash of white when he swerved.”
Hubble said Herpstreith swerved into the oncoming traffic lane, turned back into the northbound lane and stopped.
“He said, ‘I think that’s a body in the road,’” Hubble testified.
Hubble said she got out of the car and, as a certified paramedic at the time, began rendering aid to the person police later identified as Kradle.
She said there was “a very large laceration to his head” and she could feel a “very faint” pulse on his neck.
When asked, Hubble said she didn’t perform CPR because “there was not vitality of life there.”
Throughout her testimony, Hubble said she saw Herpstreith drinking at the many different parties and bars they’d both attended that night, but didn’t know what he was drinking aside from one shot and didn’t notice anything in his behavior to indicate intoxication.
During questioning by Nack, Hubble agreed that they were on a “very dark, black road” when the incident occurred and said she remembered it being “misty, hazy.”
Forensic pathologist Mark Peters testified that he conducted Kradle’s autopsy and concluded that his injuries were consistent with being run over “and partially dragged by the vehicle.”
Peters said he concluded Kradle was lying “face down” at the time of impact based on the “directionality” of two lacerations.
Cindy Sisler, a family member of Kradle’s, testified that Herpstreith was drinking alcohol at her retirement party earlier in the night that Kradle had also attended.
Herpstreith told Sisler to try his drink and said the downstairs bar at the party venue made the drinks “much stronger,” Sisler said. His drink “was pretty much straight Tito’s [vodka].”
Sisler testified that later that night Herpstreith brought two bottles of liquor to an after-party, was mixing it with blue punch and had more than one mixed drink there.
Illinois State Police special investigator Matthew Kipping testified that Herpstreith repeatedly said “he swerved” around Kradle’s body when he first interviewed him.
“The second interview that changed,” Kipping said. Herpstreith said he’d had a dream about the incident and “did not think it was possible that he did not hit Jackson Kradle.”
In response to Nack’s motion for a directed verdict, Colburn argued that the “totality of circumstances” shows recklessness.
“There is no reason for this defendant to run over Jackson Kradle unless he was acting recklessly,” Colburn said.
None of the law enforcement members who testified said they saw any tire marks indicative of braking.
Colburn argued that a person could reasonably conclude that Herpstreith was inattentive to the roadway based on the evidence and testimony presented. He also said the charges against Herpstreith don’t require prosecutors to prove he was intoxicated.
Colburn also pointed to the security camera footage that was presented during the trial of a car wash in Savanna.
Illinois State Police Special Agent Julia Deets identified Herpstreith as the individual shown on the footage that was captured between 4:03 and 4:07 a.m.
The video shows Herpstreith at a self-serve car wash, crouching at different sides of the vehicle and aiming a pressure washer underneath it. Kipping testified earlier that it was the same vehicle Herpstreith was driving on Route 78.
“That shows this defendant knew he did something wrong,” Colburn said.
Peska denied the defense’s motion.
The trial will continue at 9 a.m. Wednesday.