The Lobster Shack will be leaving Branford for East Haven.
Hearst Connecticut Media file
The Lobster Shack will be leaving Branford for East Haven.
Hearst Connecticut Media file
A Lobster Shack lobster roll
Hearst Connecticut Media file
Clams served at Lobster Shack in Branford on Sept. 2, 2018.
Derek Turner / Hearst Connecticut Media
Lobster rolls served at Lobster Shack in Branford on Sept. 2, 2018.
Derek Turner / Hearst Connecticut Media
The grounds of Lobster Shack in Branford next to the Birbarie Marine Yard.
Derek Turner / Hearst Connecticut Media
Lobster rolls and clams served at Lobster Shack in Branford.
Derek Turner / Hearst Connecticut Media
The Lobster Shack will be leaving Branford for East Haven.
Hearst Connecticut Media
Click through the slideshow to see which restaurants are serving up the summer delicacy:
Caitlin MazzolaThe Lobster Shack
540 Riverside Ave, Westport
203-226-CLAW
Open Thursday through Tuesday until 8:30 p.m.
www.ctlobstershack.com
Lobster Shack The Restaurant at Rowayton Seafood
89 Rowayton Ave, Norwalk
203-866-4488
Open daily at 11:30 a.m.
www.rowaytonseafood.comKnot Norm’s
10a First St., Norwalk
203-354-3194
ctbitesGuilford Lobster Pound
505A Whitfield St., Guilford
203-453-6122
Wednesday – Thursday: Noon – 5 p.m.
Friday: Noon – 6 p.m.
Saturday – Sunday: Noon – 7 p.m
http://www.guilfordlobsterpound.com/
Liz Mangelsdorf/SFCLobsterCraft
Abbott’s Lobster in the Rough
117 Pearl St., Noank
860-536-7719
Open daily at 11:30 a.m.
www.abbottslobster.com
Contributed PhotoBeach House Café
220 Sound Beach Ave., Old Greenwich
203-637-0367
Open daily at 11 a.m.
www.beachhousecafe.com
Knapp’s Landing
520 Sniffens Lane, Stratford
203-378-5999
Open everyday at 11:30 a.m.
www.knappslanding.comJoey C’s Boathouse
955 Ferry Boulevard, Stratford
203-870-4838
Monday – Wednesday: 11 a.m. – 10 p.m., Thursday 11 a.m. – 11 p.m., Friday-Saturday: 11 a.m. – 1:30 a.m., Sunday – 11:30 a.m. – 9:30 p.m.
www.joeycsboathouse.com
Brian A. Pounds / Hearst Connecticut MediaBill’s Seafood
548 Boston Post Road, Westbrook
860-399-7224
Open daily at 11 a.m.
www.billsseafood.com
Caitlin MazzolaBoothbay Lobster Company
14 Harbor Point Road, Stamford
203-870-9565
Opens Tuesday – Sunday at 11:30 a.m. (closed Mondays)
Cindy Schultz
The Chowder Spot Truck
2 Birdseye St. (Stratford Boat Ramp)
203-502-1234
Monday – Friday: 11:30 a.m. – 9 p.m.
Weekend times/locations vary
Facebook
rudisill/getty imagesHarbor Lights
82 Seaview Ave., Norwalk
203-866-3364
Open daily at 11:30 a.m.
Johnny Ad’s
910 Boston Post Road, Old Saybrook
860-388-4032
Open daily at 11 a.m.
www.johnnyads.com
Lenny & Joe’s Fish Tale
New Haven: 501 Long Wharf Drive, 203-691-6619
Madison: 1301 Boston Post Road, 203-245-7289
Westbrook: 86 Boston Post Road, 860-669-0767
All locations open daily at 11 a.m.
www.ljfishtale.com
Amy MortensenLenny’s
205 South Montowese St., Branford
203-488-1500
Open daily at 11:30 a.m.
www.lennysnow.com
Dave Rossman/FreelanceThe Lobster Hut
826 Bridgeport Ave., Milford
203-631-2162
Open daily at 11 a.m.
Facebook
Jon Shapley/Houston ChronicleLobster Landing
152 Commerce St., Clinton
860-669-2005
Opens daily at 11 a.m.
Facebook
Ripka’s Beach Cafe
99 Calf Pasture Beach Road, Norwalk
203-956-6060
Open daily 10 a.m. – 8:30 p.m.
Courtesy Cousins Maine LobsterJohn Carl D’Annibale
Black Duck Cafe’s Lobster Roll, in Westport, CT.
Christopher SetterSono Seaport Seafood
100 Water Street, Norwalk
203-854-9483
Open daily 11 a.m. – 10 p.m.
Stowe’s Seafood
347 Beach Street, West Haven
203-934-1991
Open daily 10 a.m. – 7 p.m.
Sunset Grille
52 Calf Pasture Beach Road, Norwalk
203-866-4177
Open daily at 11:45 a.m.
Cathy Zuraw/Hearst Connecticut MediaSzabo’s Seafood
614 Howe Ave., Shelton (storefront)
203-922-1191
Friday – Saturday: 11 a.m. – 7 p.m.
Food truck location and hours vary
www.szabosseafood.com
Westbrook Lobster
Clinton: 346 East Main St., 860-664-9464
Wallingford: 300 Church St., 203-265-5071
Both locations open daily at 11 a.m.
www.westbrooklobster.com
Robert F. Bukaty/STFMatch Burger Lobster
580 Riverside Ave, Westport
203-557-8800
ctbitesCrabshell
46 Southfield Ave, Stamford
203-967-7229
Open daily at 11:30 a.m.
www.crabshell.com
Danny’s Drive-In
940 Ferry Boulevard, Stratford
203-378-6728
Open daily, 11 a.m. – 8 p.m.
www.dannysdrive-in.com
Autumn Driscoll/STSupreme Seafood Restaurant
999 Foxon Rd, North Branford
Open Monday-Saturday 11a-9p
Sunday 12p-8p
Google Maps Street View
EAST HAVEN — The Lobster Shack, one of Branford’s most beloved summertime eateries, has served its last lobster roll in its current locale and is making the move to East Haven for a new spot opposite Long Island Sound in the former longtime home of The Beachhead.
The move comes after the Lobster Shack — which serves what are widely considered to be among the best lobster rolls in Connecticut —failed to reach terms on a new lease with landlord Skip Birbarie, owner of the adjacent Birbarie Marine Yard, said Nick Crismale, who owns the Lobster Shack with his wife, Arlene.
Article continues below this ad
Crismale said he has an agreement to buy the closed Beachhead, which overlooks both Long Island Sound in front and the Bradford Preserve lagoon and wetlands in the rear, from current owner Barbara Bucci.
They’re currently working out what Crismale termed “some complications with the property” at 3 Cosey Beach Ave. after it was discovered that part of what for decades has been The Beachhead’s parking lot actually wasn’t owned by The Beachhead, which is now closed.
The parking lot property, which has an address at 31 Cove St., has unpaid taxes and no one could identify who actually owns it, said town Director of Administration and Management Sal Brancati.
Article continues below this ad
The Crismales got some help from the East Haven Town Council last week when the council unanimously approved a request to assign tax liens to the Crismales’ Lobster Shack LLC, which will pay the $8,900 in outstanding taxes and foreclose on the property itself.
Crismale, of Guilford, who spent much of his life as a lobsterman — a job he began in 1972 — said leaving Branford wasn’t his first choice but he’s looking forward to opening the new place in East Haven.
“Branford has always been great. We really tried with the lease,” he said. “We did everything possible, beyond possible, to get a lease.”
Article continues below this ad
It had been in its current location since 2011, after several years across the Branford River.
“Believe me, we did everything humanly possible to stay in Branford,” he said of the Lobster Shack, which is right across the river from the Stony Creek Brewery. “Negotiations broke down.”
But having made the decision to move the Lobster Shack, which currently is closed for the winter, from its longtime home at 7 Indian Neck Ave., “We’re going to try to have a nice, similar kind of venue in East Haven,” Crismale said.
“We want to keep it as casual as possible,” he said.
Article continues below this ad
The new location is just a few blocks away from East Haven’s other famous seafood joint, The Sandpiper, also on Cosey Beach Avenue. But that stretch has long been home to the two restaurants and supported both for much of that time.
While the current Lobster Shack actually operates out of a trailer with outdoor seating, above which Crismale rigged a canopy they could put up when needed, the new place has both a bar and a large dining area, along with room for outdoor dining.
“I gave it a cafe type of feeling” in Branford “and that’s what we’re going to try to have in East Haven,” he said. “We just want to try to duplicate what we had in Branford.”
He said he anticipates reopening in May.
Article continues below this ad
East Haven Mayor Joe Maturo Jr. said he’s pleased to hear the Lobster Shack is coming to town.
“I’m happy to see the The Beachhead Restaurant continue as a restaurant. I think it’s an asset to East Haven,” Maturo said. “I look forward to the people of East Haven and our neighbors coming down to take advantage” of the Lobster Shack.
The Lobster Shack has gotten plenty of notice over the years, including being recognized as one of the top 10 lobster rolls in the state by Connecticut Magazine and as the home of the 11th-best lobster roll in the country in a BuzzFeed story based on Yelp ratings.
Article continues below this ad
The online travel site Trip Advisor rates the Lobster Shack Number 1 among 119 places to eat in Branford.
The Beachhead, which opened in 1942, was renowned for its seafood — including its fried seafood and its stuffed clams. It had to close from time to time, however, because of flood damage, most recently after Tropical Storm Irene in 2011 and then Superstorm Sandy in 2012.