By Bhavana Scalia-Bruce
Updated September 2026
Every year, thousands of readers nominate and vote for their favorites in dining, shopping, entertainment, outdoors, and travel in Down East’s Best of Maine poll. Here we present the five finalists for Best New Restaurant to have opened within the last year or so.
Salsa Shack | 84 Main St., Bucksport
Previously a food truck, the Salsa Shack offers a unique twist to tacos, burgers, and family fun at its new brick-and-mortar location in Bucksport. The menu has something for everyone, from shrimp and lobster tacos to its popular Crunch Shack Supreme, their take on a crunchwrap, plus occasional specials like the Chorizo Burger. Owned and run by chef Cory LaForge, Salsa Shack has a casual, laid-back feel that makes it a convenient spot to stop in and try something a little different.
The Blue Feather Kitchen & Bar | 49 Lisbon St., Lewiston
The Blue Feather Kitchen and Bar is a cozy and aesthetically pleasing spot with a full menu of appetizers, poke bowls, burgers, and sandwiches, as well as an exceptional Sunday brunch and cocktails that are as much fun to admire as they are to sip. Since its opening, the restaurant has teamed up with local partners for events like paint-and-sip nights with mobile creation station Mama Mia Making and special offerings like themed cocktails inspired by the Public Theatre’s latest show.
Cilantro Indian Bistro & Bar | 186 High St., Ellsworth
Cilantro Indian Bistro & Bar’s worth, menu comprises classic Indian favorites and creative cocktails. Chef Amol Patle creates dishes such as palak paneer and masala tikka, with an emphasis on on fresh and wholesome ingredients.The bar specializes in funky drinks like the sweet and citrusy Kiwi Breeze.
Medicini | 52 Main St., Newcastle
With a Euro-inspired vibe, Medicini feels like a getaway in midcoast Maine. Its menu features fresh, thoughtfully prepared Italian dishes like mussels and calamari, along with pasta, sandwiches, salads, and desserts. Live music, Thursday open mic nights, and community events give Medicini plenty of energy.
Wharf Street Yacht Club | 43 Wharf St., Portland
Nestled on cobblestoned Wharf Street in the heart of the Old Port, the new Wharf Street Yacht Club offers soups, salads, sandwiches, snacks, beer, and cocktails in a warmly lit dining room adorned with maritime signal flags, fishing nets, and sparkling glass fishing floats.
Curious to see who won the title of Best New Restaurant in our 2026 Best of Maine poll? Check out our September 2026 issue.
Help Us Celebrate Maine
If you enjoyed this story, I hope you’ll consider supporting Down East. For more than 70 years, Down East has been a leading ambassador and advocate for Maine — spreading stories across the country about its talented characters, chefs, organizations, and towns and places that make it so special.
When you subscribe to Down East, you help ensure we can continue reporting on the people and places that make this state extraordinary. Additionally, when you join our community of readers throughout the country, you also support small businesses across the state, including all the artists and craftsmakers that help define the culture of Maine.
In exchange for your support, you get a year of stories, stunning photography, insider guides, and that unmistakable emotional connection to Maine. You can also sign up for our newsletters for weekly updates, or give a gift subscription to share Maine with someone special.
Maine is home to all our writers, editors, and photographers, and your support will help us continue to do what we do best. Together, we can ensure local Maine journalism stays strong.
Lawrence Hollins
Publisher, Down East magazine
